Welcome to discussion
This is your opinion and i am fine with it.
For me both characters will never be as recognisable as the ones which got all the focus (except Aveline and Shay which are from Ubisoft Sofia who are also not so good in writing characters it seems). Alexios just is the baddest of them all because not just is he and empty vessel - he also has terrible voice acting. That's why i played this game in german. Eivor is better but he could have got more focus when they used the time to switch to a female Eivor more on focusing just on one male or female.
For me Kassandra/Alexios, Jacob/Evie and Eivor are the worst characters in the AC main series (i don't count Shay and Aveline to the main series). This isn't just because i hate games that let me decide which gender to choose, this is just how I feel about those characters. Even characters like Connor and Arno are way more interesting for me and would deserve a sequel. Not talking about Ezio, Edward and Bayek. The only characters where i don't want a sequel for, are the ones mentioned above. Eivor is a lot better than Kassandra/Alexios because now they tried to explain both as canon.
Nevertheless i don't want to repeat myself too often: If I think a developer can't pull of both genders in one game, than i prefer having one! If i trust the publisher and devs to deliver, than i always woul take the option with more options!
@yesin069 your preferences are opinions though, some of which I agree with, others not. I think Alexios was really well done, and I prefer him to both Bayek and Eivor b/c he's not so serious all the time, like the others all seem to be. Shay was just dull, Aveline is overly experimental for the amount of game time they gave her, and I quit Unity because it felt as grindy as Valhalla does at the end at the beginning already. Connor and Edward are both more interesting to me than Ezio. *shrug*
Of course those are just opinions. Also I sometimes watch lists of the best games and characters in the AC series. After watching nearly all of them from new and old AC fans, it looks like all the stuff from Ubisoft Quebec isn't that beloved statisticly. Odyssey is rather hated or loved but Alexios/Kassandra always seem to be at the low-end when ranking characters.
This shouldn't change your opinion that you liked them but i like that they criticise the correct things about them.
Kassandra/Alexios for me had the big problem of missing character. They were empty vessels which could be kind in one scene and cruel in another. This is the problem with decisions and bad character writing. The Witcher games had big decisions but they all fitted the character of Geralt without letting him be black or white (depending on your decission).
This is why i really dislike Kassandra/Alexios. The devs wanted more than anything to make an RPG and sacrificed the characters for it.
I can't say how Eivor fits in all the other AC characters because this is a decision that i will make when i played Valhalla with all it's DLC. Ezio has the advantage of having three games just about him. From all characters I think Bayek deserved a sequel the most. He wasn't just always super serious. He also had his lighter moments when he played with kids. I prefer that to the forced humor from Ubisoft Quebec games. From Syndicate, to Odyssey, to Immortals they always try to put in too much of their childish humour.
The World Events in Valhalla also have too much silly humour (like the farting woman). These are just things I don't like and many others too (maybe not here in this forum). Humour is always great in games when it isn't overly forced. Ubisoft should have tried more showing the curelty of vikings instead they focused too much in silly world events.
I like the idea of World Events but all that i played until now are just trying too much to be funny. Some serious one in between would be great.
@yesin069 well all the opinions I've seen are not so clear-cut, beyond Ezio that is. Kassandra, as far as I've seen is pretty popular, actually. I guess it depends upon who you are asking.
As for the Witcher, the decisions he makes that contribute to your ending are about as stupid as it gets, which isn't to say I like the game, but that in particular is dreadful.
Yes, Ezio is clearly the fan favorite. From what i've read and watched so far it seems like Kassandra just gets the upper hand when compared to Alexios (because of his bad voice acting). But Kassandra didn't get a chance against Edward or Bayek. This is just from watching a lot of AC videos lately (Lockdown and I have nothing better to do because the game is so buggy) and talking to a lot of people. Strangely just here are so many people that really like Odyssey. With all other people there was no discussion that Odyssey is a great RPG but no AC game and Alexios/Kassandra are bad characters.
This is my opinion too but I also know that they have a lot of fans. And that is the trouble that Ubisoft has brought to themselves. The fanbase that loves Odyssey wants different things from games, than the ones that prefer all games until Unity and hate Odyssey and Ubisoft Quebec in general.
I am now actually at the point where I don't will buy an AC made from Ubisoft Quebec again. It is even unlikely that I ever buy AC again after the miserable support from Valhalla. At this point in Origins the first DLC was already out (The Hidden Ones in January 2018). I don't need one need to number out the new content from Valhalla until now. What did we got: The Jul festivial (or better bug festival) and needles repeated Ubisoft Connect challenges. Bravo Ubisoft...Great work! Keep the microtransactions coming!
That is how opinions can be different...
Bayek is such a great charakter and his voice actor Abubakar Salim did such a great job. Aya on the other hand was pretty unlikable for me and better as a side character, not playable at all.
Here is a character ranking which i would do nearly the same. I just skipped the Eivor part because it is a spoiler i think and i am still not even in London in Valhalla:
Karloz1995 268 posts
i didnt like any of those games tlou2 was a joke to the gaming industry, [Removed 04/05/2021 by Ubi-Woofer], i find horizon repetitive and boring too, i liked aloy but the secundary npc, some of them were cringe as hell, thats the problem when western gaming developers make female protagonist, they kind of dont know how to writted them.. the most common message they put when they do games with female protagonist is man = bad, woman= good, man= useless, woman = strong.. always the same idiotic messages
japanese developers do a better job at doing badass female characters
i dont know more, but those are very good characters for me, that arent always screaming how useless and pathetic man are