@chaosandcoffee

When entering the longhouse from the main door in the west, it will be immediately to the right once you enter the great hall.

I've had a variation of this. After finding a first map, I collected the Snakebite scheme (figurehead), then somehow found ANOTHER map to the Oxenfordscire hoard. I went back down the well. It looked like I could collect something (and in fact I received xp when I tried), but nothing unlocked. Now there is no way to get rid if the map of the hoard in the Inventory.

I've had a variation of this. After finding a first map, I collected the Snakebite scheme (figurehead), then somehow found ANOTHER map to the Oxenfordscire hoard. I went back down the well. It looked like I could collect something (and in fact I received xp when I tried), but nothing unlocked. Now there is no way to get rid if the map of the hoard in the Inventory.

I've had a variation of this. After finding a first map, I collected the Snakebite scheme (figurehead), then somehow found ANOTHER map to the Oxenfordscire hoard. I went back down the well. It looked like I could collect something (and in fact I received xp when I tried), but nothing unlocked. Now there is no way to get rid if the map of the hoard in the Inventory.

I've had a variation of this. After finding a first map, I collected the Snakebite scheme (figurehead), then somehow found ANOTHER map to the Oxenfordscire hoard. I went back down the well. It looked like I could collect something (and in fact I received xp when I tried), but nothing unlocked. Now there is no way to get rid if the map of the hoard in the Inventory.

@dammokles

UPDATE: I've just killed the Corpse Feeders (the three wolves legendary creatures). No mounted heads there either. I suspect all future trophies are bugged.

@chaosandcoffee

When entering the longhouse from the main door in the west, it will be immediately to the right once you enter the great hall.

After killing Black Shuck, for some reason its mounted head does not appear in the Longhouse. Waiting a few days and repeatedly visiting the hunting hut has not fixed this. At this point in the game for me, the only mounted head is the stag that I killed in Norway. Playing on PC version.